← All episodes

Episode 2 · M&A · 2009

Disney / Marvel: buying an IP library with holes in it

November 13, 2026 · 26 min · Joshua Snyder

Listen to episode 2

Or follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · RSS

In 2009, Disney agreed to pay $4 billion for Marvel. Spider-Man's movie rights were at Sony. The theme park rights were at Universal. Disney bought the library anyway, holes and all. This episode covers why Disney wanted Marvel, how the deal came together, what those licenses really cost, and whether a price that looked rich at the time turned out to be one of the best deals in media.

The takeaway

When the asset comes with licenses attached, price what you control, and value what you can buy back as an option.

Chapters

  1. Cold open: the offer Maisel kept to himself
  2. The tombstone: $30 in cash plus three-quarters of a Disney share
  3. The why: what Marvel didn't own, and three theories
  4. How it came together: the 2005 film facility, then the 2009 deal
  5. The verdict: full price, then a 3.3x return on the Avengers
  6. The Lucite
  7. The takeaway

Sources

Filings, company releases and published reporting, as of October 2026.

  • Disney and Marvel joint press release, August 31, 2009
  • Disney Form S-4/A and Form 424B3 proxy statement/prospectus, 2009
  • Disney completes Marvel acquisition, Disney press release, December 31, 2009
  • Disney completes $4.24 billion purchase of Marvel, AP via NBC News
  • Pow! Disney to buy Marvel for $4 billion, AP via NBC News
  • Disney buys Marvel for $4 billion, TheWrap
  • Breaking down Disney's acquisition of Marvel, Publishers Weekly
  • Disney-Marvel: anatomy of a deal, Variety
  • Marvel 8-K on the $525 million film facility, September 6, 2005
  • Marvel Entertainment 10-K for 2008; Universal City Development Partners 10-K for 2008
  • Disney to distribute Iron Man 3 and The Avengers, TheWrap, October 2010
  • Spider-Man, the Avengers worlds collide after Sony-Marvel deal, AP, February 2015
  • Marvel Cinematic Universe franchise box office, The Numbers
  • Disney reveals return on investment for Marvel, Star Wars amid proxy fight, TheWrap, March 2024; Disney DEFA14A, March 2024
  • Bob Iger, The Ride of a Lifetime; Vanity Fair on Steve Jobs's call
  • Ike Perlmutter sells entire stake in Disney, citing The Wall Street Journal, July 2024
  • Isaac Perlmutter profile, Forbes

Transcript

Read the full transcript

0:00 It's February 2009. Bob Iger, three and a half years into his run as Disney's CEO, sits down with David Maisel, the man running Marvel's movie business. Maisel used to work at Disney. Somewhere in the conversation, Iger mentions he'd be interested in buying Marvel. Maisel doesn't tell his boss for four months.

0:25 He doesn't tell anyone. About six months later, Disney agrees to pay four billion dollars for Marvel, a comic book company that had been bankrupt barely a decade before.

0:37 Quick note before we start, Tombstones is for information and entertainment purposes only. Nothing here is investment, legal, or tax advice or an offer to buy or sell anything. The views are mine alone, not those of any company I'm involved with. I may own securities in companies I talk about. Do your own homework.

0:57 This is Tombstones. I'm Joshua Snyder. Today, how and why Disney bought the Avengers before most people knew who the Avengers were. Every other week, I take apart one deal, why it happened, how it came together, and whether it actually worked.

1:16 Last time, I promised you a comic book company that didn't own Spider-Man. Today, I'll show you why the most important move in this deal happened four years before Disney made an offer. Part one: The tombstone. The deal simplified. The buyer is The Walt Disney Company. The seller is Marvel Entertainment.

1:38 Comics, toys, licensing, and a young movie studio with exactly two films in theaters. Announced August 31st, 2009, closed December 31st, 2009, signing to closing in four months. The price. For every Marvel share, thirty dollars in cash, plus about three-quarters of a Disney share. On the Friday before the announcement, that added up to fifty dollars a share, about four billion dollars.

2:09 Marvel had closed that Friday at thirty-eight sixty-five, so Disney offered about twenty-nine percent more than the market price. The premium is how far above the market price the buyer pays. Here, about twenty-nine percent. Last episode, it was a hundred and forty-seven. Disney paid up, but nobody fell out of their chair. Because part of the price was Disney stock, the final number floated.

2:38 By closing, Disney stock was up about twenty percent. Each Marvel share was worth fifty-four dollars and three cents, and the deal came to about four point two four billion. Cash is a fixed number. Stock makes the sellers part owners of the buyer, so their price moves with the buyer's shares. Here, it moved in Marvel's favor.

3:03 They were getting a fixed number of shares despite what Disney's stock price was worth at the time of closing. The short version: Disney paid full price for a company whose main character, Spider-Man, made movies for Sony, whose X-Men made movies for Fox, whose next films went out through Paramount, and whose rides in Florida belong to Universal. Yet it might be the best deal in the history of media. Walt Disney set up the content flywheel, and Iger knew Marvel would get it spinning again.

3:45 He could sweat the assets. Part two: Why? Let's pay off that tease first. Here's what Marvel didn't own in two thousand and nine. Spider-Man. All of those movies were licensed to Sony. The day the deal was announced, Sony said its Spider-Man deal was completely unaffected. The X-Men and the Fantastic Four were at Fox.

4:11 The Hulk was at Universal, who was distributing the Hulk movies. Marvel's own next five films had sold the distribution rights to Paramount. And the theme parks? Universal Orlando had Spider-Man, Hulk, and Doctor Doom rides at Islands of Adventure. Universal's own filing says it has exclusivity east of the Mississippi for the Marvel characters it uses for as long as it keeps using them.

4:42 And for those of you who are bad at geography, Walt Disney World is definitely east of the Mississippi. How does that happen? Marvel filed for bankruptcy in nineteen ninety-six. It came out in nineteen ninety-eight, merged with Toy Biz, the toy company run by Ike Perlmutter and Avi Arad.

5:03 Remember those names. So what did Disney actually buy? It was three things. One, about five thousand characters, almost all of them B-list. Outside a comic book shop, very few people had heard of them. But behind them sat seventy years of stories. Marvel Comics number one came out in nineteen thirty-nine, and Marvel's digital library alone now holds more than thirty thousand issues.

5:34 For a content machine like Disney, that is a tremendous amount of raw material. Two, they owned a licensing machine. In two thousand and eight, Marvel's licensing business earned two hundred and forty-two million dollars of operating income. Publishing earned forty-seven million. The film business in the year of Iron Man earned a hundred and three million.

6:00 The T-shirts and the toys were the real profit engine, almost just like at Disney once upon a time. Operating income is what a business earns from running itself before interest and taxes. It's often the cleanest way to see which part of a company actually makes the money. And the third thing they owned, a studio that had just proven it worked.

6:27 Iron Man came out in May two thousand and eight and grossed five hundred and eighty-five million dollars worldwide, an absolute blockbuster. Now for the buyer's thesis. Disney had a hole, and it was boys. Coverage at the time put it plainly. Disney had lost ground with boys after leaning into franchises for girls.

6:51 Marvel shows were already running twenty hours a week on Disney XD, which Iger called, quote-unquote, "Right in the wheelhouse for boys." And Disney had a playbook. In two thousand and six, it bought Pixar for seven point four billion dollars and let Pixar stay Pixar. Buy the creative engine, leave it alone, then run what it makes through everything Disney owns: TV, toys, parks, home video.

7:23 On the analyst call, Iger said, "Sparks will fly." The seller side is the better question. Disney's CFO, Tom Staggs, said it himself, "This is not a deal that Marvel had to do." Marvel had just had a record year, six hundred and seventy-six million dollars of sales and two hundred and six million of net income.

7:48 So why sell? I have three theories, and they are just theories. Theory one, sell at the top. Marvel had two movies out and one real hit. Next up were Thor and Captain America, characters nobody had built a movie franchise on. Lock in the Iron Man price before you find out whether lightning strikes twice. Theory two, scale.

8:13 Marvel's board said it in the filing, Disney's distribution would let Marvel grow its content and licensing faster than it could alone. In licensing, Marvel ranked fourth. Disney ranked first. Theory three, the founder's exit. Perlmutter owned about thirty-seven percent of Marvel. At fifty dollars a share, it's worth about one and a half billion dollars.

8:39 When you own more than a third of the company, the question isn't only, "Is this a good price?" It's, "Is this my moment?"

8:53 Ike took a big piece in Disney stock. I think that was a bet on the future value. By two thousand twenty-four, he owned twenty-five point six million Disney shares and sold them all, roughly two point three billion at that July's ninety-one dollars a share.

9:13 Part three: How it came together. This one is two acts, four years apart, and act one is the reason that act two happened. Act one, Marvel had a problem. Other studios are making the movies, and Marvel earns comparatively little from them. In two thousand and three, David Maisel joins Marvel with a pitch: "Let's make our own movies and keep the profits."

9:39 He had a Harvard MBA, and he worked for Michael Ovitz at CAA, and then at Disney when Ovitz was Disney's president. Let's remember that. The problem with making your own movies is they cost a fortune, which Marvel doesn't have. So Maisel takes the one thing Marvel does have, the characters, and borrows against them.

10:01 September two thousand and five, Marvel announces a five hundred and twenty-five million dollar film facility arranged by Merrill Lynch. Seven years, four hundred and sixty-five million dollars of senior debt and sixty million of mezzanine debt. Senior debt gets paid back first, so it's the safest and the cheapest.

10:24 Mezzanine sits behind it, is paid later, it's riskier and therefore more expensive. If there's a loss, the mezzanine lender is gonna take it first. The senior piece is insured by Ambac, a bond insurer, which lifts it to a triple A rating, a comic book company borrowing at triple A, leveraging its comic book superheroes.

10:52 And what's pledged? The movie rights to ten characters. Specifically, it was Captain America, the Avengers, Nick Fury, Black Panther, Ant-Man, Cloak & Dagger, Doctor Strange, Hawkeye, Power Pack, and Shang-Chi. Hear that list in two thousand and five, and it's the B team. Hear it today, and it's a big chunk of the biggest film franchises ever made.

11:19 The rules: Marvel can make up to ten movies, budgets of up to a hundred and sixty-five million each, nothing rougher than PG-thirteen, and Paramount signs on to distribute. This was a clever structure. Borrow against your IP, so you can take the big swing. May second, two thousand and eight, Iron Man opens, five hundred and eighty-five million dollars in box office sales worldwide.

11:49 The bet works, and Marvel posts its best year in history. Act two, two thousand and nine. Disney had looked at Marvel before. In his book, Iger tells a story from the earlier management era. The idea of buying Marvel came up, and an executive objected, saying, and I quote, "It would tarnish the Disney brand." By Iger's account, Disney tried to reach Ike Perlmutter for six months and got absolutely nowhere.

12:20 Perlmutter is famously private and hard to reach. He served in the Israeli army in the sixty-seven war and built his fortune in toys. It probably wasn't posturing. He wasn't playing hard to get. He just is hard to get. So Iger finds a side door, Marvel's film chief, the former Disney guy, David Maisel.

12:40 February two thousand and nine, Iger meets Maisel and says he'd be interested in buying Marvel. According to the merger filing, Maisel doesn't pass it on, not to Perlmutter, not to anyone. In March, a few weeks after that first meeting, Perlmutter is granted more than a million stock options at about twenty-five dollars a share.

13:02 On June second, Iger and Maisel meet again. This time, Maisel takes it to Perlmutter. Within a week, Perlmutter calls Jeff Kaplan, a former Marvel executive who now runs global M&A at Bank of America Merrill Lynch. Then Iger does something CEOs don't usually do, and I love this. He goes to Marvel's office in Manhattan alone.

13:27 No bankers, no lawyers. He says he wanted it to feel authentic and not with a corporate army. They talk about where they came from. Perlmutter asks about Pixar, what happened to it after Disney bought it. Iger says Disney left it alone and that they would do the same with Marvel. Then they have dinner, then a second dinner with their wives, and Iger makes one more call.

13:51 He asks Steve Jobs, Pixar's former CEO, to call Perlmutter and vouch for him. Iger says Perlmutter later told him he'd still had his doubts, and the call from Steve made a big difference. Now the money. June sixteenth, Maisel opens. Disney will have to pay, quote, "A per share value starting with the number five," and it will have to be paid entirely or substantially in stock.

14:23 Disney CFO Tom Staggs says that's unlikely on both counts. Stock lets sellers keep a piece of the buyer's upside and can defer their taxes. Buyers often prefer cash because every new share they issue shrinks their existing owners' slice of the company. Here, the seller asked for stock, and the buyer wanted to pay in cash.

14:47 I think Ike saw the value in Disney stock. July tenth, Disney's first offer from Staggs, forty-six to forty-eight dollars a share, mix to be determined. July twenty-eighth, Marvel's board says no. A few days later, Disney's board holds a special meeting. Staggs comes back at fifty dollars a share as long as stock is no more than about forty percent of it.

15:15 Then 24 hours of haggling. Kaplan pushes for fifty-one or fifty-two. Staggs won't move off of fifty. Kaplan says fine if the rest of the terms work. Holding the line at a round number, each dollar a share was worth about eighty million dollars here, or about twenty-nine million dollars to Ike alone.

15:38 The last two weeks belong to the lawyers. Marvel's lead outside lawyer said his team of twenty went through every character in the library. Because when you sell characters, the question is always who actually owns what? The protections. Perlmutter signs a voting agreement covering about thirty-six percent of the shares outstanding.

15:59 And if Marvel walks away for a better offer, it owes Disney a hundred and forty million dollar termination fee. That's about three and a half percent of the price and pretty typical. A voting agreement is a big holder promising in advance to vote yes. A termination fee or a breakup fee is what the seller pays if it walks away for someone else.

16:21 Together, they tell other bidders, "Don't bother." And the 40% wasn't only Disney being careful with its shares. The agreement says that if Disney's stock falls, the cash gets cut and the stock goes up. So stock is always at least 40% of the price. That keeps the deal a tax-free reorganization for Perlmutter and his other shareholders.

16:51 If enough of the price is paid in the buyer's stock, sellers don't owe tax on the stock part until they sell those shares. They get to defer their taxes. The forty percent floor protected that for Marvel's holders. August thirtieth, both boards meet. Bank of America Merrill Lynch gives Marvel's board its fairness opinion.

17:13 Fairness opinion is a bank's formal letter telling the board the price is fair financially to shareholders. It's the board's way of performing a little CYA. It's not a promise that it's the best price out there, just that it is fair. August thirty-first, two AM, someone notices a Marvel signature is missing.

17:35 Marvel's general counsel wakes the executive up and gets it signed. Before the market opens, the deal is announced. That day, Marvel's stock jumps twenty-five percent to forty-eight thirty-seven. Disney's falls three percent to twenty-six oh four. One analyst calls it, quote-unquote, full price. December thirty-first, Marvel shareholders vote yes, and the deal closes the same day.

18:03 The one term that decided it, thirty dollars in cash. Marvel asked to be paid in Disney stock. Disney's fifty dollars only existed with mostly cash attached. Marvel gave up the all-stock deal it asked for and the fifty-two dollars its banker wanted. In return, it got certainty on most of the price and a forty percent floor of Disney stock tax-free.

18:31 Why the mix mattered more than the last two dollars, I think it's because they saw the long-term value. They got the stock, they didn't have to pay taxes. They could roll their piece of Marvel into a small piece of Disney, a much bigger company. Part four: The verdict. Let's start with how it looked in two thousand and nine.

18:58 One analyst called it full price, and on the numbers, he had a point. At four point two four billion dollars, Disney paid about twenty-one times Marvel's two thousand and eight net income and about eleven times its operating income. And two thousand and eight was Marvel's best year ever, built on one hit movie, Iron Man.

19:21 An earnings multiple is price divided by a year of profit. Twenty-one times means paying twenty-one years of two thousand and eight's earnings. That's fine if earnings continue to grow. It's expensive if two thousand and eight was the peak or an anomaly. The next yardstick, Disney's own deals. Pixar, two thousand and six, seven point four billion dollars.

19:45 Lucasfilm, twenty twelve, four point o five billion dollars. Marvel cost about what Star Wars did and a lot less than Pixar. Now, how it looks today. The Marvel Cinematic Universe has grossed about thirty-five billion dollars at the worldwide box office, counting the Spider-Man films that Sony releases.

20:07 Iron Man, the movie that made Marvel worth buying, did five hundred and eighty-five million of that. All three Iron Man movies together, about two point four billion. Box office isn't profit, it's revenue, so here's Disney's own math. In March twenty twenty-four, in the middle of a proxy fight, Disney told investors its Avengers films had returned three point three times what it spent making and marketing them.

20:35 It means for every dollar they put into making an Avengers film, they get three point three dollars back. Pretty nice return.

20:43 And here's the twist. The activist on the other side of that proxy fight was Nelson Peltz, and he was backed by Ike Perlmutter, one of Disney's largest individual shareholders. Disney defending itself with the Marvel numbers against the guy who sold it Marvel is actually hilarious. Then the missing pieces. Disney spent the next decade buying back what Marvel had already rented out.

21:10 In October twenty ten, Disney pays Paramount at least a hundred and fifteen million dollars to take over distribution of The Avengers and Iron Man three. In February twenty fifteen, Sony and Marvel agree to bring Spider-Man into the Marvel movies, co-produced by Marvel's Kevin Feige and Sony's Amy Pascal.

21:33 March twenty nineteen, Disney closes its purchase of Twenty-First Century Fox's entertainment business, and the X-Men and the Fantastic Four come home. The one piece it couldn't buy back, Florida. Universal's deal runs as long as Universal keeps using the characters, essentially forever. Here's the outside framework.

21:55 In Hamilton Helmer's Seven Powers, Marvel's characters are a cornered resource, an asset no rival can copy at any price. That's why Disney could pay full price for the B list and slowly buy back the A list. What was knowable at signing? Iron Man worked. People wanted to watch these movies.

22:16 The licensing machine threw off cash. The two thousand and five slate was set up, and Disney had already run the Pixar playbook once. What was luck? That a ten-year interlocking story across dozens of films would actually work, and that superhero movies would become the center of the box office. The case against in two thousand and nine, a peak multiple for a company with one hit, the best-known characters at rival studios, and a founder who is hard to manage.

22:48 The last part showed up later. In twenty fifteen, Disney changed who Marvel Studios reported to, and in twenty twenty-three, Perlmutter was let go. His version, "Disney fired me." The grades. Disney, A plus. It paid a good price, mostly in cash, for a cornered resource, fit it into its working machine, then bought back the rest of the pieces as they came loose.

23:14 Marvel shareholders, B plus. A twenty-nine percent premium, forty percent in Disney stock that rose twenty percent before closing, and no other bidder in sight. But they sold the MCU before the Avengers ever assembled. Does Perlmutter get his own grade? In a way. He walked away with about a billion and a half dollars and a big block of Disney stock.

23:38 Forbes now puts his net worth at nearly six billion dollars. He did all right, too. Next, the Lucite. The Lucite goes to David Maisel. He's on both ends of this deal. In two thousand and five, he created the MCU, the non-recourse facility that turned 10 B-list characters into collateral and a licensing company into a studio.

24:06 In two thousand and nine, he was the opening Iger walked through, and he opened the price talks with five words, starting with the number five. He stepped down when the deal closed. Six years later, Avengers: Age of Ultron credited him as founding chairman of Marvel Studios. The honorable mention, Steve Jobs, for one phone call that apparently changed Ike's mind.

24:37 The takeaway for anyone running a company that owns IP and might sell someday, your financing and your ability to monetize are your pitch. Marvel's two thousand and five facility didn't just pay for movies, it created proof, a studio, a slate, and a hit. That proof is what Disney was willing to pay up for.

24:58 And if you're the buyer, don't price a target by what it doesn't own. Disney paid for what Marvel could bring to Disney and bought the A-list back later, one deal at a time. If you know someone who works on deals, send them this episode. Next time, a bidding war, a billion-dollar deal everyone called dumb, and an estimated hundred-fold return.

25:21 I'm Joshua Snyder. This has been Tombstones. See you in two weeks.

For information and education only. Nothing here is investment, legal or tax advice, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Figures are from public filings and reporting as of October 2026.